The Holdovers

I did that theatrical double feature that I promised. The first film I saw today was The Holdovers, which marks Alexander Payne's first film since 2017's shortsighted Downsizing. Let's see why it's great.

It's Christmastime, 1970. Paul Hunham (Paul Giamatti) is a history teacher at the esteemed Barton Academy. This year, he's forced to supervise the five "holdover" students with nowhere to go during winter break. Angus Tully (Dominic Sessa), a troubled underachiever, is one of these students. His mother and stepfather are honeymooning, while the other four students are soon bailed out for a ski trip. He soon becomes the biggest thorn in Paul's side. Eventually, the two of them, along with head cook Mary Lamb (Da'Vine Joy Randolph), become a close surrogate family. 

This marks the theatrical debut for longtime TV writer David Hemingson. His screenplay features three compelling protagonists with memorably hilarious dialogue. Paul has plenty of audacious comebacks for his students ("I can't fail this class," protests Angus. "I truly believe that you can," Paul counters). Angus hurls back Paul's insults, with a mix of hypocrisy and obliviousness, when he accidentally injures himself at one point. Their relationship improves once they see each other as the sad and lonely guys we do. They pull through for each other when a semi-unauthorized trip threatens their academic futures.

Mary makes for a great centerpiece of this trio. Her relationship with Paul & Angus improves her outlook on life as much as she improves theirs'. She calls out Paul for his insensitivity, while she serves as the mother Angus wishes he had. All the while, she struggles with her son's death in Vietnam. She gets some subtly emotional scenes, such as a breakdown at a Christmas party and perusing through her son's baby items. She's also very funny when she needs to be. It's a great range for Randolph's performance that should warrant attention in a few months. 

Now for the others. The youngest holdovers, Alex Ollerman (Ian Dolley) and Ye-Joon Park (Jim Kaplan), are quite sympathetic. But once they go skiing, they and the other holdovers don't matter until the end. Still, the bully Teddy Kountze's (Brady Hepner) comeuppance, ice burn, is pretty amusing. Lydia Crane (Carrie Preston), the only Barton staff person who likes Paul, is herself likable. Danny (Naheem Garcia), the school's janitor, is just as funny as the leads. Gillian Vigman and Tate Donovan show up at the end as Angus's aforementioned mom and stepdad, and these two skirt the line between selfish and reasonable. Stephen Thorne is sympathetic in his one scene as Angus's dad.

The Holdovers is a foul-mouthed feel-good movie. You'll be hooked as its three central characters improve themselves and each other over the course of 133 minutes. You'll also be stunned at its colorful language. Either way, it's a future Christmas classic. See it soon while it's there for your holidays. Now, to the other film I caught today.