You know, I didn't want Mamoru Hosoda's latest anime epic, Scarlet, to straggle on my review calendar. I was hoping to review it last December, when Sony promised it would come out on the twelfth. But then ...
1. Its wide release went to February 6th.
2. When that day came, it was only available in one theater with two showings a day. One in the afternoon, the other late at night. Said theater is nearly an hour's bus ride, and my local bus system doesn't run all day.
3. On the following week - its actual, for real, wide release date - it still didn't play near me.
4. Which leads me once again to Amazon, which finally knocked down the rental price after a month.
The Review
In this take on Hamlet, Princess Scarlet (Erin Yvette in the dub) of Denmark lived a happy life with her father, the Good King Amleth (Fred Tatasciore). How good is he? When his evil brother, Claudius (David Kaye), has him executed on treason, nobody buys the charges. Scarlet then bides her time to avenge her father's foul and most unnatural murder. Unfortunately, when she finally gets the chance, Claudius hoists her by her own poisoned cup.
Scarlet finds herself in The Otherworld, which is pretty much limbo for souls across time and space. Claudius is here too, and he’s looking for the literal stairway to heaven. But if Scarlet can kill him again beforehand, he’ll fade into literal nothingness. Scarlet sets out to do just that. Along the way, she meets Hijiri (Chris Hackney), a pacifist paramedic from modern day Japan. Scarlet's quest for vengeance is thrown for a loop once she hears her father's last word: "forgive." She'll have to figure out what that means before she fades into nothingness as well.
If there’s any reason to watch it, it’s for the visuals. The technical detail in The Otherworld and its domains is nothing short of awe-inspiring. The infinite desertscape is just as striking as the gateway to infinity. The sky looks like an ocean, where a thunderous, vaguely explained dragon, flies through. The character animation, a blend of 3D and 2D aesthetics, is a bit rough, but it’s easy to get used to it. Meanwhile, the land of the living is animated in a more recognizable and colorful 2D style. Taisei Iwasaki's ethereal - sometimes haunting - score fits right in with the visuals, even if they're often overshadowed by the sound effects. There's even an out-of-body dance number - I'll try to explain it later.
Because it has a hard time explaining itself. Why Claudius is suddenly in The Otherworld is a mystery that's somewhat solved in the coda. But how did he build his own Kingdom of the Undead so suddenly? How did Amleth's four executioners wind up in The Otherworld too? On whose side Scarlet & Hijiri on when Claudius' undead army starts storming for Heaven? What's the deal with the old woman (Juanita Jennings) who pops in and out? And what exactly is the Dragon? Hosoda probably wants you to figure them out for yourself. But even the smartest viewers might have a hard time wrapping their heads around the nature of Amleth's last words. After all the glorious fighting and Claudius being such a despot while alive, Scarlet forgiving him is a bit narratively underwhelming. I say a bit, because it leads to an interestingly proactive take on Hamlet Act 3, Scene 3.
It's pretty easy to get behind Scarlet's quest for vengeance. On the one hand, she and Amleth share an endearing father-daughter relationship in the brief screentime they have. On the other hand, Scarlet's quest hasn't diminished her capacity for kindness, as evidenced by her interactions with a refugee girl. She and Hijiri have great chemistry together, even if it's somewhat hobbled by the screenplay. One of their best scenes together is the aforementioned dance number, which is kicked off by him singing a pop song by lute (Aaron Encinas sings for Hijiri). The other big moment is their last. Again, a better fleshed out script could have made it perfect.
The film's renditions of Rosencrantz & Guildenstern (Ian Cardoni & Michael Yurchak) are as dopey as they are legitimately creepy. They're responsible for one of the film's biggest gut punches; the other one is the manner of Hijiri's mortal death. Queen Gertrude (Michelle Wong), despite being practically complicit in Claudius's coup, just frowns around for most of the film. It kind of makes it funny when she runs off at the end. Voltemand & Cornelius (Jamieson Price & Tatasciore), the more sympathetic of Amleth's executioners, make for pretty good allies. The other two executioners, Polonius & Laertes (Jason Marnocha & Yuri Lowenthal), are practically unrecognizable from Hamlet, but are still decent bad guys.
Despite its imperfections, I'm at least relieved to have finally seen Scarlet. Sure, it doesn't live up to Mirai or especially Belle, but it still exemplifies Hosoda's technical prowess. It's worth checking out at least once, specifically on the biggest screen you have. You'll understand why once you see The Otherworld. I think I've said enough.