Universal hit it big in 2000 with Jim Carrey in How the Grinch Stole Christmas. But when they made Mike Myers The Cat in the Hat in 2003, practically nobody liked it. Dr. Seuss’s estate promptly forbade any more live-action adaptations of his work because of it.
Universal got a chance with The Lorax, and another with The Grinch, both times animated. And now, it’s Warner Bros.’ turn with The Cat, this time with Bill Hader voicing said feline. It’s a decent time, indeed.
The Cat in the Hat is employed by the Institute for the Institution of Imagination and Inspiration to cheer up kids on rainy days. He leaves them satisfied and destruction in his wake. His boss, Mr. Hoogeboom, wants him out, but Sherri from HR (Quinta Brunson) persuades him to give the Cat one last case.
This time, he’s sent to cheer up Gabby (Xochitl Gomez) and Sebastian (Tiago Martinez), who have just moved with their mom, Carmen (America Fererra), to a new town. The Cat brings with him a Go-Backer, a stopwatch that reverses time around its users - perfect for fixing messes. Gabby decides to fix her move with it, but it falls into one of her family’s three moving boxes. The Cat and the Kids travel by couch to find which box it is.
Oh yeah, there’s also a Something, a monstrous thing that wants the Go-Backer like it’s the One Ring. They’ll have to hurry up and find the Go-Backer before it, Mr. Hoogeboom, or the kids’ new landlady, Patty (Paula Pell), make things worse.
Since the book is so short, directors & writers Erica Rivinoja & Alessandro Carloni naturally had to find some way to expand the plot. Besides the whole Institute business, they do so with clever sight gags and inspired bits of silliness. Their emotional through line, however, is mostly slight and surface level stuff. For example, Gabby’s apprehension with the move just boils down to “I hate it here.” Did she have any friends she misses from the old town? It improves, though, after Patty threatens to flush the kids’ sentient goldfish, Waffles (Matt Berry). Now those are palpable stakes.
I also have issues with the villains. Admittedly, Giancarlo Esposito’s clearly having fun playing Mr. Hoogeboom as a dastardly bad guy. He’s a law-abiding jerk, much like Patty, as he points out the Cat’s selfish thrill seeking. But in another twist, it turns out that he might have taken one of The Cat’s past incidents out of context. That never gets brought up, for he instead gets his comeuppance off-screen. Patty, meanwhile, has a change of heart that would be ludicrously quick in any other film. Granted, the catalyst is also silly, but it’s still horrifying if you dig deeper.
Now, what about The Cat? He may be loud, and a little oblivious, but he’s surprisingly pleasant to be around. He may be messy, but at least he means well. The aforementioned plot twist gives him another meaningful surprise. He’s matched by Waffles, who has most of the film’s funniest dialogue. They meet some weird characters in the box worlds, but the most significant one is a “Psychic Narwhal” (Titus Burgess). More memorable are The Cat’s Institute colleagues, which include Pig in a Wig (Ryan Gaffney), Gary the rich Intern (Bowen Yang), Rat with a Bat, and especially Sherri from HR.
Oh yeah, let’s not forget the Things, who number everywhere but 2 (there is a reason for that). Their character designs, along with everyone else's, are delightfully eclectic. No one thing looks like another. The Things’ slaphappy communication is surprisingly tolerable.
Its strongest asset is its artistic styles. The Institute and its residents are rendered in cel-shaded CGI, while the real world is rendered in “normal” CGI. It’s an interesting contrast, to say the least. Its best gag has The Cat come into a monochrome house, presumably the same one in the book, only to find the kids glued to their tablets (great satire). The house brightens up when he gets to work; they even love the messy aftermath. There’s some great production design in each world, with a favorite being the Institute's massive supply closet.
All things considered, this Cat in the Hat isn’t likely to make the Geisels roll in their graves. If anything, it's greatest sin might be that it might not mean much beyond a rainy-day matinee. I still had fun watching it, and I'd rather take its sense of humor beyond its 2003 predecessor's crass one. I'd say that's all folks, but there's something else:
It kicks-off with a new Looney Tunes short, Daffy Season, in which Daffy (Eric Bauza, posthumous) desperately tries to get his soccer-obsessed co-stars (mostly Jeff Bergman) that it's Duck Season. Its rough art-style works best when it pivots to comedic horror, while Bauza and the other voice actors are entertaining as always. You'll just have to see it for yourself.
Now, That's All Folks!