I can’t wait for The Social Network 2!
Fear not, Buck, for we now have its “spiritual companion,” The Social Reckoning. Aaron Sorkin writes, and this time, directs this continuation of Mark Zuckerberg’s (Jeremy Strong, tagging-in for Jessie Eisenberg) ultimate success story. This time, we’ll see how it’s everyone’s problem.
Huh?
In 2019, the computer illiterate Jeff Horwitz (Jeremy Allen White) becomes The Wall Street Journal’s newest tech reporter. Meanwhile, Frances Haugen (Mikey Madison) joins Facebook’s Civic Integrity Team, and is already at a crossroads. She discovers that Facebook’s algorithm is pushing users down rabbit holes full of extremism and misery. Her former friend, Kayleigh (Portia Doubleday) is case-in-point.
Jeff is assigned to cover Facebook’s activities and ends up meeting Frances. Despite her inside info - at great risk to her NDA - he needs concrete evidence before it goes to print. That happens during that pandemic, and thus, Horwitz starts publishing The Facebook Files.
Meanwhile, in 2021, Zuckerberg prepares to testify before Congress over Facebook’s influence. He prides himself a “free-speech absolutist,” until something forces him into an impossible choice. I’ll give you a hint: I started this film just as it happened.
Sorkin’s screenplay mostly takes a “just the facts” style of reporting. We’re told how Facebook’s algorithm contributed to extremism and cyber-bullying. But we rarely see it in action for ourselves. For example, Frances tells Jeff that Kayleigh used to be progressive, but there’s no before to her after. When we first see her, she intentionally loses the plot when two non-white officers, Deputies Diaz & Otumbo (Sierra Capri & Michael Braugher), try to help her during car trouble. She ends the movie having learned absolutely nothing, as does Facebook. While Frances is suspected by her supervisors, they barely pose any tangible threats. It’s much more tense when certain world events loom on the horizon.
Let’s get into the technicals now. The work by returning cinematographer Jeff Cronenweth and new composer Alexandre Desplat (tagging in for Reznor & Ross) is fine, but it’s not special either. Its most visually interesting aspect is the Facebook control room where Zuckerberg makes that choice. You can thank production designer Jon Hutman for that, along with his recreations of Facebook’s offices. Alan Baumgarten, taking over editing duties from Baxter & Wall, switches back-and-forth between Zuckerberg and Jeff/Frances’s storylines with a handy sliding timeline graphic. His best work comes when he builds up to a certain something…
Physically, Strong’s resemblance to Zuckerberg still has me double-take. Personality-wise, he’s nothing like the fascinating egomaniac in The Social Network. He’s mostly stiff and stoic when he talks business, free speech and the business in free speech. He gets his best moments when the fictionalized Charlie Garrigan (Bill Burr) gets under his skin. Their antagonistic history prints a picture I would have loved to see ages ago; I spent the movie wondering if he was someone I missed in The Social Network.
Did you think I was being mean when I called Jeff “computer illiterate?” In his first scene, he admits being unable to work his car’s GPS, much to his editors’ (Betty Gilpin’s Kris & Gbenga Akinnagbe’s Andy) exasperation. When he meets Frances, he admits being a “tech reporter…ish.” White does a good job making him a likable dork, who’s also a surprisingly tenacious reporter. He and Frances are enjoyable together, whether on the case or discussing movies. Alone, Frances coming out of her shell is engaging, as is her confrontation with Morgan (Anna Lambe), who turns out to be a fellow whistleblower.
Anyone else? There’s also Raya (Wunmi Mosaku), Facebook's crisis manager, who spends the movie coaching Zuckerberg's testimony. Billy Magnussen is Teddy Marks, Facebook's media relations executive and the closest, but not quite, to a heavy. Kris is enjoyably quirky, and she gets her best scene when she exercises her editorial authority. Its most enjoyable supporting characters are Zach & Evelyn (Aidan Laprete & Kelly Pereira), Jeff’s computer-savvy interns. In many ways, their contributions cannot be understated.