Hey, Daisy Mae, you might want to take this one!
Ah, The Sheep Detectives! Don't mind if I do.
Over twenty years since they debuted, the ovine sleuths of Leonie Swann’s novel Glennkill (aka Three Bags Full) are now movie stars in The Sheep Detectives. That's the kind of title that tells ewe what it's all about. Let's see what else it is.
So, we have George Hardy (Hugh Jackman), a shepherd just outside of Denbrook, England. He doesn’t care for most of the townsfolk, but he’s all for his flock. Each night, he reads them a mystery novel, even if they can’t understand a word he’s saying. But amongst themselves, the flock have a lot to say. Lily (Julia Louis-Dreyfus), in particular, is usually on the ball about the killers in each story. But death is a foreign concept for them until the morning they find George dead - actually dead.
As the town's only cop, the inept Tim Derry (Nicholas Braun), gets on the case, Lily leads the flock in their own investigation. Her co-investigators include Mopple (Chris O'Dowd), who remembers everything; Sebastian (Bryan Cranston), the loner; twins Reggie & Ronnie (both Brett Goldstein); Cloud (Regina Hall); and Sir Ritchfield (Patrick Stewart). They've got a few suspects, including Caleb (Tosin Cole); Ham (Conleth Hill) the Butcher; Elliot (Nicholas Galitzine), a visiting reporter; and Rebecca (Molly Gordon), George's previously unknown daughter. Can they help steer Officer Tim to the right one?
One can easily dismiss it as silly fluff - which it is - but they’d be surprised at how poignant it gets. George’s death is an existential shock for Lily, which she can't blank out like most of her flock (and a more cavalier film) could. You'll definitely feel for her as she confronts the truth of the world (which involves another sinister secret). One sheep's death flags are raised from a mile away, but the actual moment still hurts. Still, it gets philosophical and funny when Sebastian talks about God, or when the inquisitive sheep Zora (Bella Ramsey) questions the meaning of life. You'll have to see those moments for yourself.
Its poignancy wouldn't work if we didn't like George. Thankfully, Jackman makes him quite enjoyable in life, and even beyond that (including in Lily's dreams). As for his fellow humans, Officer Tim going from loser to gumshoe is quite compelling, while Rebecca is pretty likable. Denbrook's residents, which also include innkeeper Beth (Hong Chau) and Rev. Hillcoate (Kobna Holdbrook-Smith), are a delightfully quirky bunch. Emma Thompson walks over the scenery as George's lawyer, Lydia Harbottle. As for the killer, they get so much screentime I wonder if Msgr. Knox would cry foul. But I digress.
Of course, the real stars of the show are the flock, and what's more to say? They all have great personalities and voicework behind them. You'd be surprised at how much you can learn about sheep, particularly the differences between spring and winter lambs. How is that relevant? One winter lamb (Tommy Birchall) is ostracized by the flock until he helps save the day. Anyway, this lamb and the rest of the flock were visualized by some very convincing CGI. Not a single sheep is out of place, and it's hard to tell if shepherd Kyle Balda got some real sheep too. Even if you can tell they're computerized, you'll stop caring very early.
Needless to say, The Sheep Detectives is an excellent murder mystery. Its delightful ensemble of animal sleuths and their ewe-nique perspectives are sure to entertain everyone in your herd. Hopefully, it can follow Babe to a Best Picture nomination at the Oscars and bring a few more names - like writer Craig Mazin and composer Christophe Beck - along for the ride. It's anything but baad. Just flock on over to your local cineplex for a splendid matinee.
I've said enough.
Wow, you've nailed just about the same points I would have!