About five minutes, maybe less, into Whalefall, the projector suddenly dimmed then went to black as the sound still played. It quickly got fixed and reset, so all was right in the end. Unlike what happens to Jay Gardiner (Austin Abrams) here.
Jay is looking for his dad, Mitt (Josh Brolin), or what’s left of him. A year earlier, Mitt allowed the sea to take him rather than cancer. Their relationship was rough, but Jay figures this is the best way to get closure. Jay takes an hour of air and years of Mitt’s scuba diving lessons for his mission.
During the dive, Jay witnesses a sperm whale pursuing a squid. The petty cephalopod grabs Jay just it goes down the whale’s throat. Now, Jay has to get out of the belly of the beast before either his oxygen or luck runs out. That’s the gist of it.
Daniel Kraus, with director Brian Duffield, adapted his own novel for the screenplay. During which, Jay’s setbacks are accompanied by flashbacks to life with father. For some, they are too frequent, too dull and too many. For me, they’re pretty interesting in how they gradually plant the seeds of Jay’s salvation. Chances are that you’ll remember even the tiniest details by the time they come back for the climax. After the aforementioned fiasco, they were welcome proof that the projector still worked.
As with Resident Evil, Abrams’ performance makes the implausible scenario believable. Due to the whale’s toxic atmosphere, Jay is often forced to convey his physical and emotional pain through his respirator; he suffers a lot. He is so believable that, when he frantically cries out for his new “friend” and light-source, a Jelly Fish, to stay awake, it’s as moving as it is silly. That comes when he nearly escapes, with he even crying out to a tour boat that can’t hear him. It just makes his eventual escape and rescue all the more moving.
Jay’s complicated relationship with Mitt is well-acted, even if somewhat typical. What I found fascinating about Brolin’s performance was that, even at Mitt’s worse, there’s some tangible emotional pain. To his credit, Mitt shows off some of the goodness everyone keeps saying he has. Some of his best moments come when Jay imagines the whale speaking in his voice (yes, really). Still, it’s kind of weird that he wanted Jay to be his own man, but his taskmaster attitude contradicts it. But I digress.
John Ortiz, as Mitt’s buddy Hewey, is the only other prominent human cast member. The silent prologue, where Hewey breaks down during Mitt’s suicide, tells you everything about their relationship. We also get Elisabeth Shue as Mitt’s wife, Zara, and Jane Levy & Emily Rudd as daughters Eva & Nan, but they’re mostly sidelined by the plot. Now, who do we have behind the camera?
By far, the biggest technical star is production designer Ramsey Avery, who visualized the whale’s innards with very realistic sets. While the forestomach, where Jay spends most of his plight, is alluringly bio-luminescent, the gastric acid heavy fundic stomach is the stuff of nightmares (thankfully, we don’t tour the pyloric stomach). You’d think that what we see of the whale’s mouth is CGI, but nope, it’s another set! Cinematographer Aaron Morton really sells us on Jay’s claustrophobic plight, as well as the beauty of the ocean around him. The actual CGI, meanwhile, is excellent, as is the brutal makeup work.
It’s also an excellent movie to listen to. Its nautical soundscape, both within and without the whale, is spectacular. When Jay’s ears pop due to water pressure, the sound effects are perfectly sickening. Joseph Trapanese’s stirring score is a lot easier on the ears, even when things get dire. Its soundscape means nothing if they aren’t paired with its visuals. A black screen for 106 minutes is only half a movie. Unless it’s designed that way like Derek Jarmen’s Blue, but this is different.
Instead, you really should be thinking about 127 Hours. Over a decade ago, Danny Boyle made a compelling movie about a man pinned to a boulder. This year, Whalefall is a compelling movie about a man stuck in a whale. You can ignore the implausibility of it all thanks to its strong central performance and technical work. See it soon; hopefully, your screening will go smoother than mine.