Matt Hagen (Tom Rhys Harries) is Gotham City’s biggest movie star and newly minted Oscar nominee. At a party, Matt dances the night away with Mia Torrez (Joana Ribeiro), the dame of Gotham’s nastiest mob boss, Markos Szabo (David Denick). When Szabo catches them, he and his goons carve up Matt’s face. Everything else soon goes wrong for Matt, and he’s left a destitute nobody in the slums.
Matt comes across Dr. Caitlyn Corr (Naomi Ackie) & her skin-repairing nanites, and volunteers for human trials. They work, for a solid minute, so he self-administers the whole supply at his follow-up. Soon enough, Matt can heal any injury and shapeshift into anyone, just as long as he’s emotionally stable. When he’s not, the results aren’t pretty. It’s also not pretty when Matt goes after everyone who ruined him, and anyone who might stop him.
Quite frankly, there’s a lot about Matt that should’ve been on the page and/or the stage. For one thing, we barely see his career before Szabo, not even the film that got him Oscar-nominated (whose title is barely audible). For another, and more important thing, Matt gets slandered when he tries to have Szabo prosecuted. What kind of allegations, other than Mia’s accusations, aren’t even acknowledged when Matt crashes a movie premiere. He’s just welcomed back now that he has a face (good points for satire, though). Better elaboration could’ve helped its point that, perhaps, Matt wasn’t that nice to begin with.
That’s not saying that Matt is a blank slate. Far from it, for Harries’s charismatic performance shapes Matt into quite the character. It’s easy to get behind Matt when the world sets him up to fail. It’s even easier to tremble when he starts fixating on Caitlyn, especially after he comes into his powers. And yet, even after he turns villainous, you’ll still feel a bit bad for him. His makeup work deserves a spot on the Oscar-bakeoff, if not the ballot itself.
As Caitlyn, Ackie is pretty good as a scientist in over her head. She’s got a sympathetic backstory behind her research, which gets explored fairly well. One of her few mistakes is not taking safety measures to prevent a self-administration, but that’s a surprisingly believable blunder. She’s otherwise professional, and she’s prepared to deal with Matt when it gets bad. Believe me, you’ll share her dread when he starts turning stalker, even during a sleep test. Overall, Ackie’s rather engaging in what could've been a routine role.
They’re surrounded by a decent supporting cast. Some of the highlights include Max Minghella as John Borelli, Caitlyn’s fiancĂ© and the only Gotham cop on Matt’s side; Joshua James as Corey Bowery, Matt’s best bud; and Eddie Marsan as Frank Fitzpatrick, Matt’s treacherous manager. Mia, despite being rather vapid, still cares enough about Szabo’s henchman Patches (Jake Curran) when the boss shoots him and a disguised Matt. Pity she doesn’t have the same pity for Matt, or maybe that was written out (it’s plausible). Szabo, meanwhile, is decently monstrous. And finally, we have Vic Chissler (Rob Brydon), Gotham’s biggest talk show host, whom Matt briefly invokes as the devil on his shoulders (more or less).
Liverpool once again stands in for Gotham, just as it partially did in The Batman. While not as stunning as the earlier film, cinematographer Rob Hardy and production designer James Price get some good gritty mileage out of the city. A few highlights include Szabo's nightclub, as well as an ally where Matt ambushes one of Szabo's goons. There's some way obvious CGI for Matt's clayness, but there's also some excellent body horror in there, too. Jon Harris, who was Oscar-nominated for editing 127 Hours, pulls off some excellent tension when Matt cuts open his melting eyelids on a turbulent flight. If I have any complaint about Matt's final form, it's that it's smaller than I thought it would be. Other than that, it's a very pitiable creature, all things considered. As for music, we have another excellent Volker Bertelmann score, as well as a sudden dance scene that's surprisingly less weird than The Bride's.