The Greatest Showman

The Greatest Show on Earth, The Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus, ended its long history last year. We now have a musical biopic about its co-founder, PT Barnum. Step right up and hear all about The Greatest Showman. And see if this is worth your time.

PT Barnum (Hugh Jackman) was a poor tailor's son. His father's client, Mr. Hallett (Frederic Lehne), didn't think much of him. But PT gets to marry the old man's daughter, Charity (Michelle Williams). They live a nice life in New York with their two daughters. PT finds good work at a shipping company until it's literally sunk. PT invests in a museum of curiosities. But nobody seems to care about the lifeless exhibits in Barnum's American Museum. So he puts on a show with living curiosities: little people, bearded ladies, Siamese twins, etc.

Barnum's Circus is the talk of the town. The public loves it but some don't like the "freaks" on display. One critic, James Gordon Bennett (Paul Sparks), denounces the show for its cheap exploitation of its performers. Barnum shows him off by booking opera star Jenny Lind (Rebecca Ferguson) for his show. But Barnum's ambitions threaten to isolate him from his family. What's a showman to do?

It's the directorial debut of effects artist Michael Gracy (Ned Kelly), who works from a script by Jenny Bicks and Bill Condon. The film's historical liberties may make or break the film. There's a lot of unsatisfactory parts of Barnum's life the film skims over. The film makes a point about Barnum shoving his performers aside when Lind arrives. That leads to their rousing number, This is Me. But their reconciliation with Barnum seems a bit rushed. A few of these performers are barely presences in the film. What were they like in real life? If there's one thing it gets right, it's that they never have Barnum brag "there's a sucker born every minute."

Jackman's performance makes the film work. His Barnum is still a great trickster even if he wasn't a scoundrel. He gets a bank loan through a swindle; that was pretty funny. His showmanship was entertaining to see. Zac Efron also makes an impression as Barnum's business partner, Phillip Carlyle (who's apparently a renamed James Bailey). His romance with African-American trapeze artist Anne Wheeler (Zendaya) is the film's B-Plot. The main Circus performers, like diminutive Charles Stratton (Sam Humphrey) and especially bearded lady Lettie Lutz (Keala Settle), were memorable characters. Gayle Rankin gets the film's best cameo as Queen Victoria.

A whopping six editors, including Oscar winners Tom Cross and Joe Hushting, managed the film. Their best trick is making it appear it was the work of one; it was that cohesive. Why six? I don't know. The production and costume designs, as well as Seamus McGarvey's cinematography, make a great vision of old New York. The makeup designs were also perfect. Benj Pasek and Justin Paul have another fine playlist of musical numbers. A few of these numbers run a bit too long, but you'll remember them sure enough. There's also a score by John Debney and Joseph Trapanese but it's overshadowed by the musical numbers.

The Greatest Showman isn't a documentary of the real Barnum in anyway. It's still a fine fictionalization of the man. It makes a good effort to tell the story of how some people rose above prejudice. It's also a good reminder not to let fame swell one's head. It's not perfect but it's still a good movie musical. Maybe this will inspire people to read up on the history of Barnum. That's a lot of reading to do.