The Black Phone may have been a short story, but when a movie is good enough, Hollywood finds a way to make a sequel. Fortunately, the sequel they've dialed up, Black Phone 2, is pretty good. I've got quite a few fitting titles for this Halloween season, so let's go.
We now find Finney Blake (Mason Thames) in 1982, a few years after he permanently disconnected the evil Grabber (Ethan Hawke) from the mortal coil. He's now a jaded stoner who gets into fights and avoids phones whenever possible. Meanwhile, his psychic sister Gwen (Madeline McGraw) converses with her late mom, Hope (Anna Lore), in her dreams. It turns out that mother and daughter are both dreaming of the same place, Camp Alpine Lake, where the Grabber began his murderous career. Joined by their classmate Ernesto Arellano, whose brother Robin was the Grabber's penultimate victim (both played by Miguel Mora), the Blakes head off to Camp.
A massive blizzard immediately snows in our heroes at Alpine Lake. They're accompanied by supervisor Armando (Demian Bichir); his niece, Mustang (Arianna Rivas); two sanctimonious employees, Barbara & Kenneth (Maev Beaty & Graham Abbey); the ghosts of the Grabber's first three victims; and the Grabber himself. The Grabber plans to kill Gwen in her dreams, which will kill her for real. Our heroes can de-power the Grabber by exhuming his first victims from their frozen lake grave. They'll just have to stay awake as long as possible; but that might not be enough.
While some might scoff at The Grabber becoming Freddy Krueger, I think it's a natural development for him. What else was he going to be other than dead? The film's new setting doesn't quite amplify his menace as much as the first film's basement. But Hawke still gives it his all as this force of giddy malevolence. He wants vengeance, something he takes too long to spell out to Finney, and he's going to have fun doing it. We’ll enjoy watching Gwen take him down in one dream, before teaming up with the others to finish him off in the final battle.
Finney mostly takes a backseat for Gwen to become the protagonist. The only hiccup with this arrangement comes when he clobbers a new kid jobber in his first scene. A little more on-screen context would make this re-introduction a little less jarring, but I digress. Anyway, Finney gets plenty of time to shine as he deals with his traumatic ordeal, especially during a major breakdown in Act 3. Gwen, meanwhile, proves quite compelling as she deals with not just The Grabber, but her own psychic powers. A few developments, plus one last ghostly phone call, give Gwen the film's most emotional moments. At least we get some levity with her creative insults.
Now, a few words for the rest of the cast. Ernesto proves himself to be a pretty good guy during this ordeal. Mora wonderfully distinguishes Ernesto and Robin between the two movies. Amongst the staff, Armando is a pretty good mentor; Barbara & Kenneth are annoying, but not that annoying; Mustang is just fine. Jeremy Davies returns as the Blakes' dad, Terrence, who thankfully doesn't relapse into abusive dad territory despite his drinking. I think that's enough for them.
Now, we go to Scott Derrickson's directorial panache. He filters the Dreamworld through a home video aesthetic that, surprisingly, remains consistently terrifying, especially when it weaves in and out of reality mid-shot. The action scenes are pretty spectacular as editor Louise Ford switches between an invisible and "actual" Grabber. Ford and cinematographer Pär M. Ekberg go great together, particularly when Finney is surrounded by the ghost boys. As the camera circles around Finney, trapped in the Camp's "dead" phonebooth, the ghosts teleport between blind spots. It's so seamless! Derrickson's son, Atticus, accentuates the dread with his wonderful score.
Go ahead. Accept the charges and pick up this sequel. I don't know how Black Phone 2 compares with this month's horror slate, but it's still a delightfully spooky time. See it however and whenever you can. I think I said enough.